The Human Compass
What is it to be human, now that machines can write, draw and talk?
Where do you stand?
Episteme’s next issue asks, “What is it to be Human?” This quiz puts that question to you in the age of AI. Answer 28 short statements, about eight minutes, and you will be placed on a map with two axes. There are no right answers.
Given ↔ Made
What is a human? Something fixed and given, or something we make together?
Guard ↔ Embrace
What should we do about AI? Hold the line, or shape what comes?
Then you will see everyone else who has taken it, and where they stand.
The map is closed, so new results are not being added. You can still take the quiz for yourself, or look at the map.
This quiz belongs to Episteme’s call for the 2027 issue. Submission guidelines →
Your place on the map
What the five results mean
Each result is a way of answering both questions at once: what is a human, and what should we do about AI? None is better than the others, and each has serious thinkers behind it. Yours is open; open the others to see what they hold, and what they would ask you.
The SentinelGiven · GuardYou believe being human rests on something that is not ours to revise, and that AI puts it at risk. Your task is to say where the line runs, and to hold it.
What this view holds
- There is something in being human, a nature, a soul, a dignity, that does not change with history or technology.
- Machines may imitate us, but imitating a person is not the same as being one.
- Some roles and decisions should stay with humans, however good the machines become.
What it worries about
That each convenience quietly moves the line, until nobody can say what was worth protecting.
What it hopes for
That we draw clear limits in time, and keep what is most human out of the reach of the market and the machine.
A question to put to it
Where exactly does the line run, and who decides when it has been crossed?
Thinkers in this corner
- Hans Jonas argued in The Imperative of Responsibility (1979) that the power of modern technology calls for a new ethics of responsibility for the future of human life.
- Jürgen Habermas argued in The Future of Human Nature (2003) that remaking human nature through genetic enhancement would threaten how we understand ourselves as free and equal persons.
The ToolmakerGiven · EmbraceYou believe human nature endures and is strong enough to master any tool, AI included. For you the danger is misuse, not the machine, and the task is to build well.
What this view holds
- Humans have a stable core: reason, dignity and the capacity to choose.
- AI is the latest in a long line of tools, from the plough to the printing press, and people remain its authors.
- What matters is who uses a tool and for what. Good rules and good purposes beat fear.
What it worries about
That fear of the machine distracts us from the real risks: bad uses, bad owners and bad laws.
What it hopes for
That AI frees time, widens access to knowledge and care, and leaves people better able to live as they choose.
A question to put to it
If human nature is that steady, why have tools so often changed how we live and think?
Thinkers in this corner
- Immanuel Kant held that every person is an end in themselves and never merely a means: a rule for how tools may be used on people, not a reason to refuse them.
- John Stuart Mill wrote in On Liberty (1859) that human nature is not a machine built to a pattern but a tree that must be free to grow, and trusted freedom and progress to improve life.
The CyborgMade · EmbraceYou see the human as a work in progress, remade by language, tools and each other, and AI as the next chapter, to be shaped rather than feared.
What this view holds
- Being human has always been made: through language, culture, care and the tools we use.
- The line between human and machine is blurry, and it has moved before. It may move again.
- We should take part in shaping the next change, not stand outside it.
What it worries about
That clinging to one fixed idea of “the human” shuts out people, and other beings, who do not fit it.
What it hopes for
That new partnerships between people and machines widen who counts, and what we can do and be.
A question to put to it
If anything can be remade, is there anything we should refuse to change?
Thinkers in this corner
- Donna Haraway imagined the cyborg, part organism and part machine, in A Cyborg Manifesto (1985) as a figure that breaks down fixed boundaries between human, animal and machine.
- Andy Clark argues in Natural-Born Cyborgs (2003) that humans have always extended their minds into tools, from writing to phones.
The CriticMade · GuardYou believe humans are made, which is exactly why it matters who is making us. AI built for profit and power remakes work, attention and relationships in its own image.
What this view holds
- What it is to be human is shaped by society: by work, money, law and technology.
- So the question is not only what AI can do, but who owns it, who profits and who has a say.
- Technology is never neutral: it carries the interests of those who build and own it.
What it worries about
That AI deepens alienation and inequality, with people measured, managed and replaced for someone else’s gain.
What it hopes for
That AI is brought under democratic control and shaped for shared purposes, not private profit.
A question to put to it
If people are made by their conditions, what would a better making look like, and who would do it?
Thinkers in this corner
- Karl Marx wrote in his sixth thesis on Feuerbach (1845) that the human essence is “the ensemble of the social relations”, and in Capital traced how machinery reshapes work.
- Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno warned in Dialectic of Enlightenment (1944) that reason, once it becomes a tool of domination, turns against the freedom it was meant to serve.
- Bernard Stiegler held that technology is part of what makes us human, and argued that today’s digital tools can also wear down attention and knowledge.
The ScepticNear the centreNo camp has fully persuaded you yet. That may be the best place to start: the question is still open.
What this view holds
- The questions are hard, and the strongest argument on each side deserves a hearing.
- Some of the answers depend on facts about AI that nobody knows yet.
- Holding back judgment can be a position, not a failure to take one.
What it worries about
That rushing to a side, in either direction, makes us stop looking at what is actually happening.
What it hopes for
That patient questions, asked in public, lead to better answers than certainty does.
A question to put to it
What would you need to see or learn to move towards one of the other four views?
Thinkers in this corner
- Sextus Empiricus described the ancient practice of suspending judgment, not as giving up inquiry but as a way of keeping it going.
- Michel de Montaigne took as his motto “What do I know?” (Que sais-je?).
The room
Scan the code, or go to epistemejamia.in
Where the room agrees and disagrees
The room is most divided on
The room agrees most on
| Name | Result | Given–Made | Guard–Embrace |
|---|
Nobody matches that yet.
Reach out to us
Queries, suggestions or submissions. We'd love to hear from you.
editor@epistemejamia.inFollow us on social media also
Stay in the loop
New issues and posts, straight to your inbox.